Puzzle | IMGpapers 1976

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR) from a scan of a newspaper page, and the page was cut into articles by machine, at the headlines found by their type size. Nothing has been corrected: expect misread words, text from a neighbouring article, and titles that are the machine reading of the headline, some of them only fragments. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found by type size in the OCR geometry (split_tabloid.py); 2-2 of 7; machine-segmented newspaper page; uncorrected Vision OCR.

page 10 of the scan

Duncan Hallas fails to explain how a society without capital or capitalists, and in which, according to Cliff in his book State Capitalism in Russia, the law or value las Doch suppressco l favour of state planning, can exist int any form.

But the rejection theory of Stalinist necessarily leads to a rejection of the theory of permanent Since the mode of production China and Cuba, for qualitatively the same as in Russia, Hallas and the SWP must explain how state castransin arose.

Socialist Challenge 8 November 1979 Page 10 have been SWP. the puzzle capitalism theory of state of Trotsky's explain how degeneration revolution.

revolution. remarkable writers example, La peasant movement!

But in Cuba and China these tasks accomplished. For the How? Their explanation, to be consistent with the capitalism, has wasn't On China, Hallas comes up with a theory. Other SWP pointed the . LO overwhelmingly peasant composition of the Chinese insurrectionary army. But Hallas is emphatic: '1949 was not