So much is of course clear 1o the average reader of this epochal work, this work which has not only transformed collective perceptions of rabbitness (Koninchentichkein but which has contributed a new chapter to the political economy of the cahhage patch. It is our contention in this brief monograph that Peter Rabbir marks a watershed in sophical development, ological rupture from the earlier problematic of the Herne Bay manuscripts (above all, The Tale of Squirrel Jemime Puddleduck).
Nothing more tellingly illustrates the completeness of this scientifie metamor. plosis than the contrast between rather schematic Nutkin-Puddleduck period LI2S0 of the principles of comparative political economy manifested Rabbir. The dramatisation of the conflict between Peter and Mr. MoGregor in the celebrated garden points, in a so brief episode contradictions and levels mination characteristic cabbage production The revelatory stance (Potter's favoured methodological device) is that 'moment"
McGregor, chasing Peter garden, seizes the rake and the fleeing creature. Through Mroke of transformative which the essence the from that of t00l Potter lays bare the onisms of a sub-feudal order in which the role of producer LITE TERESOURH patible in their binary opposition I is quite clear the unpublished drafts and revisions carly McGregor is to embodiment (Trager) of small peasant proprictors from whom baronial landlords extracted in direct and unmediated forms surplus value in the dual forms of military service and corve labour. However, we must state quite emphatically that despite certain surface sinslarities the role of Mr. MoGregor in the productive process our Potter's phil distinct enisemNukin and the in Peter those acute of overdeterof pre capitalis Inwhen Mr. the an inspired Take changes that of irresolvable and the role of warrior linked yet totally incom Trom our reading of manuscripts that Mr. understood as an that CELS le uacked TENTAS The Quality Restaurant Open all day until 11pm English and continental dishes Also to take away Shish kebab and Turkish dishes First class service with civility Tel: 01-226 0837 5566666G cquated with that of the Seven Dwarls, as so many theorists from Schumpeter onwards have argued The extraction of surplus from productive labour of the Seven Dwarfs by the Royal Household (Soon Whitel was a medicied political form, though ultimateup hy terror. condition more akin lo the Asiatic mode of production than to sub-Feudalism Failure to appreciate this crucial disinc tion has led to quite understandable among the readers of these - though untortunately we cannot go into the important question of whose self-interests are in fact being served by ROSA and CHARLIE PARKIN the which is these not accidental attempes at mystifi cation and concealment The thesis we wish to advance is that the entire cpisode beiween Peter MeGregor, quite apart Trom the scene is decisive in marking a con uncture in the transformation of Peser object ol history to the subjoct of history, It is precisely at chut "moment when Peter is threatened by the trake that he pets his blue jacket caught on the fence, and can only make good his escape by abandoning it. Agaio, in this capsule statement we have Patter's brilliant portrayal of the self-emancipatory act have in a sense prepared us.
Nonce the draft of Peter expresses serious internal Structure is a racit recognition Tull welchcing проп Tiesy M can only be accounted the over determination instances within the gi farmiyard. What cised bedgehog to imagine Polter ITHE in any Our attempt answering this who sock virtualls to the level of a fairy 1. Enid Biyler Maspere and Mr rake Rabbi LXIV 119701 G. Lukaos, Wellpeis Resig-Dorter Srudion. VIlE 11958 19/21.
********* Cottontail (who chose to remain in the ever-pre-given structure of the warren) as a figure of destiny: the singular and heroi Figure for which all Potter's carlier works previous manuscripts matches the theretic presence - including the much Tale of Mrs. Tiggy Winkle which, norwitbstanding Lukacs' extrava gaut assertions to the contrary, still bears the unmistakable traces of the Herne Bay period." It is quite clear from a sympto matic reading of the Preface to the second edition of the Czech translation of Tigg Winkle, published after the linal (Pitney)
Rabbit, that Porter rescivations about the of the argument. • failure give forces bearing inkle's actions which for as a conjunctive en coralicy of the his as i in ellect is to present us with a completely de-historisubject - It is impossible falling into the sume later analyses of pre-caputalist economic formations.
produce Teading of Peter Rabbir deliberately poses the problem of what it is to read. Only question can wC Teel confident in our lask of rescuing Patter's contribution to science from the hands of rechuce this Tale 2. Sen Nicod Foulanizes, Hegemeny, Surplus Patch, a reply to Mil bend in New Left Review 4. Acoro's biting comment is herd very much to the point. The though: 1o which a positive ance of the dialecte la forolcden. cvershools as being one. T. Adomo, Spasms (Franklur
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE, 15-31 Decamber 1977, page 20
----- pull-quotes -----
SEASONS GREETINGS Indian Restaurant 79 Mortimer Street, London W1 16 Albemarle Street, London WI 69 New Street, Birmingham